Celebrity3 min(s) read
Miss Universe winner ended relationship with NFL boyfriend due to 'rule' that meant he refused to have sex with her
Olivia Culpo, who won Miss Universe in 2012, has been in the spotlight for many reasons over the years, both for her beauty queen accomplishments and her personal life. Culpo, born in Cranston, Rhode Island, first gained national attention after winning Miss Rhode Island USA and Miss USA in 2012 before taking home the Miss Universe crown the same year.
She later made a mark as a co-host for the Miss Universe competition from 2022 to 2024 and became a social media influencer with partnerships with major brands like L'Oréal, Kipling, and Uberliss.
In her personal life, Culpo's relationships have drawn considerable interest, especially her time with NFL star Tim Tebow. Tebow, known for his time with the Denver Broncos and New York Jets, was reportedly dating Culpo back in 2015. However, their relationship ended, with some reports suggesting that the breakup was due to Tebow's religious beliefs and his choice to maintain his virginity until marriage.
The role of religion in Tebow's personal life
Tebow's commitment to his faith and his vow of chastity were widely publicized, particularly when he admitted in 2009 that he was a virgin and planned to remain so until marriage. This personal choice, rooted in his Christian values, became a defining feature of his public persona and seemed to influence his romantic life as well.
In an interview with OutKick’s "Don’t @ Me with Dan Dakich" in 2023, Tebow said, “What Jesus has done for me is everything. So, my faith hasn’t really cost me anything. My faith in Jesus and what Jesus has done for me has given me everything.” Tebow's relationship with Culpo reportedly ended partly because of his unwillingness to engage in sexual activity due to his commitment to his faith.
Despite this, both Culpo and Tebow have moved on to new relationships. Culpo later began dating NFL running back Christian McCaffrey in 2019, and the two married in 2024. They welcomed their first child, a daughter named Colette Annalise McCaffrey, in July 2025. Meanwhile, Tebow married Demi-Leigh Nel-Peters, Miss Universe 2017, in 2020, and they too became parents in 2025.
Life after the breakup
Both Culpo and Tebow have found happiness in their respective marriages and families. While Culpo’s relationship with McCaffrey appears to be flourishing, with their new child and continued professional success, Tebow and Nel-Peters are also navigating parenthood and life together. Despite the differences in their personal choices, both have maintained strong public profiles and continued to influence their audiences, especially on social media.
The breakup between Culpo and Tebow, while private, sparked significant media interest, particularly due to the unusual circumstances surrounding it. However, both individuals have continued their lives in the public eye, each finding success in their own way.